Direct Outside Air Systems (DOAS) and traditional Air Handling Units (AHUs) are both used in building HVAC, what are the key differences?

Featured \ MTI Monthly Blogs

Direct Outside Air Systems (DOAS) and traditional Air Handling Units (AHUs) are both used in building HVAC (Heating, Ventilation, and Air Conditioning) systems, but they serve different purposes and have distinct advantages and disadvantages.

Direct Outside Air Systems (DOAS)

Benefits:

1. Improved Indoor Air Quality: DOAS units supply fresh, conditioned outside air directly to the occupied spaces, improving indoor air quality.

2. Energy Efficiency: They can be more energy-efficient, particularly in buildings where internal loads are high. DOAS units pre-treat the air, reducing the load on other HVAC systems.

3. Humidity Control: More effective in controlling humidity as they can dehumidify the incoming fresh air separately.

4. Reduced Size of Other HVAC Equipment: Since DOAS handles most of the ventilation load, other HVAC components like air conditioners can be smaller.

Pitfalls:

1. Higher Initial Cost: DOAS systems can be more expensive to install due to the need for separate ductwork and additional controls.

2. Complexity in Design and Operation: They require careful design to integrate with other HVAC systems and can be complex to operate and maintain.

3. Potential for Over-Ventilation: Without proper controls, DOAS can lead to over-ventilation, increasing energy costs.

Traditional Air Handling Units (AHUs)

Benefits:

1. Simplicity: Traditional AHUs are relatively straightforward in design and operation, making them easier to understand and maintain.

2. Flexibility: They are versatile and can be designed to meet a wide range of building requirements.

3. Cost-Effectiveness: Generally, traditional AHUs have a lower initial cost compared to DOAS.

Pitfalls:

1. Lower Indoor Air Quality: Since AHUs typically recirculate a large portion of indoor air, they might not provide the same level of fresh air as DOAS, potentially affecting indoor air quality.

2. Energy Efficiency Challenges: Balancing energy efficiency with adequate ventilation can be more challenging, especially in buildings with high occupancy or pollutant loads.

3. Humidity Control Issues: AHUs may struggle with humidity control, especially in humid climates, as they mix fresh air with recirculated air.

Conclusion

The choice between a DOAS and a traditional AHU depends on specific building requirements, including indoor air quality needs, climate, energy efficiency goals, and budget constraints. DOAS systems offer better control over ventilation and indoor air quality but at a higher cost and complexity. Traditional AHUs are simpler and more cost-effective but might not meet the same standards for air quality and energy efficiency.

Service Area: HVAC Test and Balance

Tags: hvac system performance \ Independent testing \ energy efficiency \ Commissioning \

‹‹ Previous

Next ››

Tips, Traps and FAQs

If your HVAC BMS controls have a bunch of outdated overrides in them, your burning money! HVAC overrides of heating and cooling valves cost building owners and operators $10,000's of dollars a year if left unchecked. Commissioning your BMS will save you money this year! Make it part of your Preventive Maintenance routine annually

Each year 100's-1000's of man hours are lost to construction companies because of pour or no, virtual drawing coordination. Reality Capture allows for existing buildings to be 3D Scanned and imported directly to AutoDesk so designers can create your new design based off correct and current conditions of the building environment. Saving the project$

Here is short video of MTI Test and Balance Engineer, Brian Venn discussing an Independent approach to TAB and why we are a proud member of AABC!

AABC - Independence Matters

Drones can be used for many different applications. Our inspections offer drone solutions for construction that can significantly reduce costs of many items. Specifically, they can eliminate the need for costly lifts in many circumstances. Drone use is a valuable option for construction companies. MTI offers different services for the construction.

Continued Commissioning is a process that works to improve how equipment in the building and systems function together. There are many variables that come into play, the age of the building or system being one and how the sequence of operation is managing the daily equipment routines.

MTI believes in Full Project Awareness and that is exactly what a 3D Scan provides. MTI has a state of the art Leica RTC360 3D reality capture solution. MTI will capture your environment in 3D. Export it into a manageable Point Cloud that is ready to be converted into a working RVT file.

Building Commissioning is the practice that ensures buildings are delivered according to the Owner's Project Requirements (OPR). Buildings that are properly commissioned typically have fewer change orders, tend to be more energy efficient, and have lower operation and maintenance cost. DO NOT Value Engineer Commissioning out of your next project

Symptoms of a building with an Air Balance issue:
Entry way doors "howl" and are difficult to open or won't remain closed. Odor issues in storage areas, break rooms or worse...bathrooms! Frost forms on window sills in the winter. High and Low Temperature areas in a building. Cooling problems in the summer – no matter how long the AC runs.

Change filters every six to eight months. Did you know that dirty air filters can lead to Dirty Air? Dirty air filled will allergens like pollen and mold can lead to sick time in the work place. Sick time means reduced productivity... do we need to go on? They also put wear and tear on your HVAC system meaning you will have to replace it earlier.

NEXT
Tip